Headlines >>
Three Killed in Ukraine as Diplomats Meet - Thursday, 17 April 2014 09:56
Tensions Rise in Ukraine's East Ahead of Talks - Thursday, 17 April 2014 09:49
The World This Week - Sunday, 13 April 2014 05:57
NBA Finals: Miami Heat beat San Antonio to level series
Last Updated on Jun 19 2013

NBA Finals: Miami Heat beat San Antonio to level series

LeBron James scored 32 points as Miami Heat beat San Antonio to tie the series 3-3 and take the NBA Finals to a decisive seventh...
G-8 Syria Statement Won't Mention Assad's Stepping Down, Russia Says
Last Updated on Jun 19 2013

G-8 Syria Statement Won't Mention Assad's Stepping Down, Russia Says

ENNISKILLEN, Northern Ireland -- The G-8 summit's joint statement on ending the Syrian civil war will not mention whether Bashar Assad...
Afghanistan Suspends U.S. Talks
Last Updated on Jun 19 2013

Afghanistan Suspends U.S. Talks

    Afghanistan suspended security talks (BBC) with Washington that had been aimed at shaping the U.S. military presence in...
“From Toussaint to Price-Mars: Reflections on Haiti’s Intellectual History”
Last Updated on Jun 18 2013

“From Toussaint to Price-Mars: Reflections on Haiti’s Intellectual History”

In Haiti’s intellectual history, Toussaint Louverture is not only a man of deep commitment to his people but also the great Haitian...

Featured Posts



Connect with JSF Post

Best of the rest

Bolivia: End of the Road for TIPNIS Consulta

  • Thursday, Dec 13 2012
  • Written by  EMILY ACHTENBERG
  • font size decrease font size increase font size

December 7 marked the formal conclusion of the Bolivian government’s controversial consultation process with communities in the Isiboro-Sécure Indigenous Territory and National Park (TIPNIS), to determine the fate of a proposed highway that would bisect their ancestral lands.

According to official data, of the 69 indigenous communities included in the consulta, 55, or 80%, agreed to support the road. Three were opposed, and 11 boycotted the process. All but one of the participating communities rejected the park’s current “intangible” status, which the government has interpreted as prohibiting community development activities as well as megaprojects like the highway.

For the government, the results of the 4+ month process (which began on July 29) represent a “triumph of representative democracy” a successful outcome of Bolivia’s first experience with the “consulta previa” for indigenous communities that are mandated by the new Constitution and by international law. But for indigenous, environmental, and human rights groups concerned about the adverse effects of the road, the outcome of the consulta was a foregone conclusions that President Evo Morales was determined to achieve, through a process of deception, manipulation, and cooptation that casts doubt on the final results.

Fernando Vargas, head of the TIPNIS Subcentral (one of three indigenous governing authorities in the territory, and holder of the communal land title), insists that at least 30 communities rejected the consulta. In many cases, he argues, the official consulta included only a minority of residents and took place without the sanction of indigenous authorities. For example, in Gundonovia, a focal point of resistance to the highway, local leaders charge that a “surprise consulta” was held in a private hacienda an hour’s walk from the village, during a torrential rainstorm. According to the government, the location was chosen to avoid conflict, at the request of villagers (allegedly more than 60%) who wanted to participate.

Vargas also claims that TIPNIS residents were confused and deceived by the government’s effort to link support for the road with promises to deliver basic services and other community benefits. Community support for these projects, he argues, was taken as an endorsement of the road.

Indeed, in conjunction with the formal conclusion of the consulta, the government has promised to create an integral development plan for the TIPNIS, emphasizing sustainable development projects, the delivery of basic services such as education, health, and transportation, and protection against land encroachments and exploitation of natural resources. Financing for these initiatives will be guaranteed by the national, departmental, and municipal governments, under a mandate equivalent to the “ten commandments,” according to Vice President Alvaro García Linera. Vargas emphasizes that the provision of these benefits and services is a fundamental obligation of government, and should not be in any way contingent on the highway.

Some indigenous leaders have publicly stated that while their communities have agreed to support the road, they are opposed to its passage through the heart of the TIPNIS and uncertain about its benefits. In response, the government has promised to develop an “ecological highway” that will minimize any adverse environmental impact, with a 10-mile central stretch to be elevated at treetop level or submerged underground.

According to a group of Cochabamba engineers, the feasibility of this type of construction is questionable under the geological conditions that exist in the TIPNIS. They say it’s impossible to construct a road that will not damage the park or will protect it against land invasions. The proposed 10-mile viaduct or tunnel, they note, could cost as much as $400 million—equal to the total cost of the 180-mile highway from Villa Tunari to San Ignacio de Moxos under the original contract with Brazilian company OAS.

On International Human Rights Day, Bolivia’s human rights ombudsman Rolando Villena issued a harsh critique of the consulta, which he characterized as “authoritarian, colonialist, and unilateral.” In addition to failing to comply with international requirements for a consulta previa (before financing and construction commitments), to be carried out in good faith and in accordance with indigenous customs and governing structures, he argues, the process did not achieve the agreement of all parties, as required by the Plurinational Constitutional Tribunal (TCP), as a condition of its constitutionality.

 The government says it has complied with the TCP ruling by reaching out to all communities, honoring their right to refuse consultation, and achieving 80% support—though not consensus (the usual requirement for decisions in indigenous communities), or backing from the TIPNIS Subcentral, the key indigenous authority. According to Villena, the government’s actions may be legal, but do not have legitimacy.

Villena’s final report, based on a reconnaissance of the TIPNIS communities, is expected in February. Another fact-finding report, by an independent commission comprised of the Catholic Church, the Permanent Assembly of Human Rights in Bolivia (APDHB), and the Inter-American Federation of Human Rights (FIDH), will be issued next week. The group’s preliminary findings indicate significant irregularities in the consulta protocol, including discrepancies in the communities reported to have been consulted, as well as considerable popular discontent with the process.

Also due next week is the official report of the Supreme Electoral Tribunal (TSE) charged with monitoring the consulta, which will include the official written record and audio and video documentation of the process.

Despite the conclusion of the consulta, the TIPNIS road is a long way from being built. The design process is expected to take at least a year. Currently the road lacks funding, as well as a contractor.

For their part, communities opposing the road have vowed to take their concerns to international tribunals and to physically resist construction of the highway, if and when the time comes. It may be the end of the road for the TIPNIS consulta, but not for the TIPNIS conflict.

Emily Achtenberg is an urban planner and the author of NACLA’s weekly blog Rebel Currents, covering Latin American social movements and progressive governments (nacla.org/blog/rebel-currents).

Read 3464 times
Rate this item
(0 votes)

12 comments

  • Comment Link http://www.sound4u.net/ Saturday, 12 April 2014 11:59 posted by http://www.sound4u.net/

    I never should have viewed an iPhone 3gs. You have to cover monthly successful cost same as line rental.
    Jailbreaking provides you with better control
    over a great deal of other activities on the iPhone.

  • Comment Link acheter litecoin Tuesday, 08 April 2014 11:25 posted by acheter litecoin

    Comment commander du litecoin anonymement via paypal tout de suite

  • Comment Link kung fu academy Saturday, 22 March 2014 05:25 posted by kung fu academy

    I really like looking through an article that can make people think.
    Also, many thanks for permitting me to comment!

  •  Start 
  •  Prev 
  •  1 
  •  2 
  •  3 
  •  4 
  •  Next 
  •  End 

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated. HTML code is not allowed.

NEWS

  • Three Killed in Ukraine as Diplomats Meet
    Three Killed in Ukraine as Diplomats Meet   Ukrainian security forces killed three separatists in eastern Ukraine in a firefight that left thirteen wounded and sixty-three captured. The incident has shed the most blood yet ten days into a standoff with pro-Russian separatists that has highlighted the challenges the security forces will face in reasserting authority there (NYT). Ukraine's financial situation is also testing the government's legitimacy: an International Monetary Fund bailout seeks to root out corruption and waste, but residents are bracing for short-term economic pain (WaPo). Thursday's clashes came as Ukrainian, Russian, and Western diplomats arrived in Geneva in a bid to defuse tensions. Additional sanctions are expected if…
    Written on Thursday, 17 April 2014 09:56
  • Tensions Rise in Ukraine's East Ahead of Talks
    Tensions Rise in Ukraine's East Ahead of Talks   The Ukrainian government continued its campaign to restore its authority in the country's east while avoiding bloodshed as armed pro-Russian separatists continued to defy the military, raising tensions on the ground the day before talks on the country's future are set to begin in Geneva (Reuters). As both sides made shows of force, some Ukrainian troops were reported to have defected to the separatist side, another setback for the government as Russian president Vladimir Putin warned that Ukraine was on the verge of a civil war (WaPo). Meanwhile, NATO secretary-general Anders Fogh Rasmussen announced the Western alliance will reinforce its military presence…
    Written on Thursday, 17 April 2014 09:49
  • Worst Climate Change Scenarios Can Be Averted, Panel Says
    Worst Climate Change Scenarios Can Be Averted, Panel Says   The worst consequences of global climate change can be averted, but only if governments act quickly and aggressively, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change said in a new report, released in Berlin on Sunday (WSJ). The UN-sponsored body emphasized that action to contain warming to 2 degrees Celsius over preindustrial levels would have "modest" costs to the economy, and new technologies have made efforts more affordable (AP). This is the third of four IPCC reports in the periodic review; previous installments said human activities caused warming and that warming's effects were already destabilizing human society (NYT). A global treaty is supposed to be completed…
    Written on Monday, 14 April 2014 18:23
  • The World This Week
    The World This Week   Defining India's Role in the World Alyssa Ayres The main opposition Bharatiya Janata Party offers a vision of India that emphasizes alliance and growth, invoking a view of the country's past as one of traders, scientists, and economic leaders, a position damaged by colonial rule and one necessary to recover. Read more on Asia Unbound » Three Questions for the IMF and World Bank Robert Kahn This week's IMF/World Bank Spring meetings take place amid significant global uncertainty. The meeting's broad agenda should cover questions of global confidence in growth, reform of the IMF, and the risk of inflation. Read more on Macro and…
    Written on Sunday, 13 April 2014 05:57
Saturday, Mar 22 2014 1 comment
Becker's turn to abandon his post
  Joker will now be on his own in Key B, after Boris departed to have hip surgery for a long-standing
Tuesday, Sep 17 2013 12 comments
Who is Aaron Alexis?
Who is Aaron Alexis, an employee at a defense contractor, who died Monday in a gun battle with police at the

JSF Post Bookshelf

  •  
    Book Review by Jean Junior Fleury: Tony, the main character of the book, becomes very friendly with the owner of the corner grocery store Mr.
     
  •  
    Edouard Glissant opens his monumental 1981 book of essays “Le discours antillais” with the bold declaration “Martinique is not a  Polynesian
     
  •  
    1. HARDCOVER FICTION 1. Flight Behavior, by Barbara Kingsolver, Harper  2. Gone Girl, by Gillian Flynn, Crown  3. The Round House, by
     
  •  
    Review of the book, Haiti: The Aftershocks of History by Laurent Dubois Review by E. Ablorh-Odjidja   A book on Haiti that I think is a
     
  •  
    Amazon.com, book review - Publication date: October 24, 2011 Based on more than forty interviews with Jobs conducted over two years - as well as
     

Highest rated

Latest Stories

Three Killed in Ukraine as

  Ukrainian security forces killed three separatists
Read more

Tensions Rise in Ukraine's

  The Ukrainian government continued its campaign to
Read more

Worst Climate Change

  The worst consequences of global climate change can
Read more

The World This Week

  Defining India's Role in the World Alyssa Ayres
Read more

Satellites Show Ready Russian

  Satellite photographs from NATO revealed a
Read more

Ukraine Moves to Regain

  Troops from Ukraine's Interior Ministry expelled
Read more

U.S. Review Role In Mideast

  Secretary of State John Kerry said Friday that the
Read more

Yanukovich Admits Mistakes on

  The Ukrainian government took a step toward
Read more

Obama Seeks to Narrow Rift

  U.S. president Barack Obama arrives Friday in
Read more

Venezuela Arrests Three

  Venezuela arrested three air force generals accused
Read more

Haiti Quake Survivors

Life inside Port-au-Prince's Tent Camps 10 months after the earthquake. Jean Senat Fleury revisits a Tent Camp in Port-au-Prince, Haiti (Champ de Mars)   http://www.jsf-post.com

Stock Market

Loading
Chart
o Dow Jones 16,426.36 ▲1.51 (0.01%)
o S&P 500 1,866.54 ▲4.23 (0.23%)
o NASDAQ 4,102.33 ▲16.10 (0.39%)
INDEXDJX:.DJI

Dow Jones

Company ID [INDEXDJX:.DJI] Last trade:16,426.36 Trade time:2:50PM EDT Value change:▲1.51 (0.01%)
INDEXSP:.INX

S&P 500

Company ID [INDEXSP:.INX] Last trade:1,866.54 Trade time:2:50PM EDT Value change:▲4.23 (0.23%)
INDEXNASDAQ:.IXIC

NASDAQ

Company ID [INDEXNASDAQ:.IXIC] Last trade:4,102.33 Trade time:2:50PM EDT Value change:▲16.10 (0.39%)

Book of the month

proces des timbres 09877

Le Procès des Timbres: L'affaire Audubon

By Jean Sénat Fleury The scheme was simple. In Haiti in 1975 greedy and corrupt members of the Jean Claude "Baby Doc" Duvalier regime faked exquisite renderings of bird watercolors by native son Jean-Jacques Audubon and put them on the world market...  Buy it now!

FOLLOW Us

L'Écho

Health and Lifestyle

MOST VIEWED